Saturday, 16 August 2008

A brief hiatus

Another pause in blogging from me, I'm off on vacation for a couple of weeks far, far from civilization and the digital world.

More on my return...

The job of Auto Focus

With all the discussion going on in web land about Rob Galbraith's analysis of Canon 1D III AF performance, I have been missing one important thing: objective analysis of whether this is expected behaviour or not, and how it relates to the tolerance of the system. I've mentioned this before. This is the engineer in me wanting to analyse the thing and see if it's doing what I'd expect and thence, what changes would be needed to make it do what I want (if possible). This is a general discussion, applicable to any camera. It will be fairly technical but I hope even non-scientists will be able to follow it.

This got me to thinking, what exactly is an AF system doing and what results should we expect? This, then, is the result of me breaking down the job of AF so I can get a feel for how much we should expect. I figured readers might find it interesting, hence the post. Please, if you find any factual errors, leave a comment and I'll make corrections.

I will not talking about how focus is measured. I am going to assume that whatever AF is implemented, there is an objective, measurable system for determining focus that is in place. There are a two main ways of achieving this (phase detection and contrast detection) and from the perspective of AF, the actual focus measurement method is irrelevant here (as will become clear).

Defining terms

First of all, there are some important terms I'm going to use in the discussion, and some abbreviations.

Focus Tolerance (AFTol) - the range in which the subject is determined to be in focus by the AF
Focus Accuracy (AFAcc) - the degree to which the focus approaches optimal focus
Sample Frequency (FSamp) - the rate at which the AF system checks for focus

Focus toleranceThe red dot is the subject, the solid line is plane of focus, dotted lines represent focus tolerance (AFTol). Gap from solid line to red dot is the AFAcc.

Open loop - a system of control where a measurement is taken, error calculated and the controller moved to desired position. There is no feedback whether the point that the controller moved to is correct. This is how most AF works in SLRs: degree of out of focus is determined and the lens moved to where the AF thinks focus is.
Closed loop - a system of control where the degree of error is constantly checked. For AF, this involves moving the lens and then rechecking whether focus has been achieved.
Feed forward - A system of control where the measurement predicts into the future and then moves the controller where is expects the system to be needed. For AF of moving subjects, this would be the system employed for predictive AF, where the subject speed is determined and the focus moved to predicted next location. it can be applied in either open or closed loop mode.

The gamut of AF

Next up, what are the situations we need the system to cover? I reckon we've got three of them: static subjects, slow approaching subjects, fast approaching subjects (a retreating subject is just a negative approach). For the moving cases there are also steady and erratic speeds. We also need to consider AF under single shot and rapid fire. So that's a lot of operating cases to cover.

In the industrial world with a wide variety of operating modes, we would normally expect either to cover each case with a separate control scheme, or accept compromises in performance on the lesser ones, to hit the important ones. With cameras, that's going to be difficult: who's to say what's important? A landscape photographer is going to want different things from a sports shooter.

Allied to this are the AF control modes used to achieve the desired results. In general, there are 3 types: single shot, continuous and predictive. In the first case, focus is acquired once and applied to all shots in a sequence (which may have just 1 frame), the second checks focus for each frame, the third tries to get ahead of things with moving subjects by predicting where the subject will be on the next frame. In any case, open or closed loop may be applied but it is normal for current systems to use open loop control (i.e. measure once, move as desired).

Let's go through the main cases:

Static subject - fairly simple. Subject sits there, nice and steady, focus is achieved, shutter gets pressed. Think mountains, castles, cooperative portrait subjects. Focus needs only be achieved once.

Slow approach - subject moves forward slowly relative to the response of the camera. It is important to consider relative speed, compared to the camera, rather than absolute speed. More on this later.

Fast approach - subject moves relatively quickly relative to the sped of the camera. Of course high absolute speeds will be involved but the point when a subject moves from being slow to being fast will vary from camera to camera.

And now a quick look at the main AF modes

Single shot, single frame - focus is achieved once, there is one press of the shutter. Best used for static subjects. If open loop control is in place it will be almost impossible to catch moving subjects in this mode.

Continuous focus, multiple frames - With open loop control, the focus is acquired between each frame, producing a continuous shift of focus across the frames.

Predictive focus, multiple frames - The AF feeds forward the estimated speed to move the focus to where it expects the subject to be. This will require at least 2 measurements of focus (and therefore subject) position to be able to sense motion.

What are the implications?

OK, so we know what it's all doing, how does this work in practice? And how do things change as camera specs change?

First up is the notion of focus tolerance versus desired accuracy. A camera will think that a subject is in focus if it lies in the the tolerance bands. If it moves within the bands, the AF is likely to be unable to detect the motion (important later on). If, however, we can perceive, in the final picture, out of focus even within the tolerance range, then the tolerance isn't tight enough. In general, as megapixel count goes up, so this discrepancy gets bigger (manufacturers don't move their definitions of tolerance much).

Then we come to the relationship of subject speed and focus speed. If a subject moves slowly relative to the focus tolerance, then it may be hard to detect the motion (see figure below). If the first couple of points are within tolerance, it would take a third for motion to be detected. This would then lead to over-compensation 9front focus) as the subject is deemed to have moved twice as much as it actually has.
Slow movement relative to focus tolerance. Subject moves 1-2-3 but system only detects movement 1-3, shifting focus A-B for point 4 (now front focussed).


If rate of fire (fps) increases, then the speed that is "slow" in relation to the focus actually increases - the subject moves less between shots. Implication is that higher fps cameras have harder job with approaching subjects that may have been OK for slower models. Just slowing shutter speed may not help as the sample frequency won't change, unless the camera is set up to spend more time on focus for slower modes.

For relatively fast motion, things are better because the motion can be detected between frames (see below).
Fast speed - subject moves 1-2-3. AF detects motion 1-2 and moves A-B for point 3. Subject is in focus for subsequent shots.

If fps goes up, however, the fastest speed that can be focussed may go down as it is harder to move the lens between frames.

My conclusion

Faster camera, with higher resolution actually make focus worse, unless the focus tolerance is changed. Doing anything else won't help much. As fps increases, AF has less and less time to react, and will find it harder and harder to detect subject movement, unless tolerance is smaller or focus is able to detect movement within the range of focus tolerance. Resolution will make focus appear less and less precise.
Closed loop control doesn't help if the AF ha the same tolerance as open-loop. all it would do is minimise the chance of overshoot and provide a chance to correct, but that takes longer than just controlling to a more accurate position in the first place.

Wednesday, 13 August 2008

Image qualities aren't necessarily measurable

Some great points at the Landscapist on the techno-weenie discussions on-going about micro 4/3. Summed up: the mockers state that IQ will be poor due to smaller than other sized sensors.

There's not a thing as "Image Quality", there are image qualities, and because they are qualities (rather than quantities) they are by nature subjective.

The current talk that all shot have to be perfectly noise free at the pixel level at EI 1 gazillion, misses the point about qualities of images. back when getting ISO1600 meant grainy black and white, I don't think there was a hankering after ISO25 like smooth tones. The high speed leant itself to particular kinds of situations and images and conferred certain qualities therefrom.

There is one aspect to the digital techno babble that I can relate to (but rarely gets mentioned) and that is about lost changes. By that I mean desirable things left out, or undesirable things added, which mean we are stuck with undesirable results. Mostly this gets talked about in terms of lost resolution or added noise. The point being that once we have an unrecoverable result, there is nothing more we can do. However, there are too few talking about what can be achieved with given parameters. Many "noisy" cameras produce very nice black and white in low light, a digital return to the days of grainy film. It is a different set of qualities conferred on the pictures.

One group who seem to buck the trend are the Sigma DP-1 fans. They seem to talk very much about what the camera can do, rather than what it can't. Of course, if you actually want it to do something it can't, it's not the device for you.

But of course, all that requires thinking, which seems to be the antithesis of modern cameras.

Monday, 11 August 2008

Kinesis Journeyman: first impressions

I've just received my new Kinesis Journeyman backpack system. I'll run through some first impressions, but first some background.

What I want in a photobackpack

I was in the market for a new backpack, my old alpine style one being unsuited for camera gear and the padding long since compressed to nothing.

I've posted before about photo backpacks. I'm disappointed by all the offerings from big names. Pressing a regular backpack into photo service is also a non-starter.

What I need is a 30-40l daypack that can carry my photo gear and my regular stuff (like lunch, water, waterproofs) comfortably in the hills. I can end up carrying 10-15kg easily on a day out. I also need to to carry my tripod and a pair of walking poles, plus all the camera bits and pieces in an organised manner.

I also want to be able to carry the photo gear near the top of the pack for better weight distribution. I prefer the tripod lashed to the side. While this sets the weight a little one-sided (I've often got a side pouch on the other side anyway), it is also closer to my back, which is more important to me.

Must have a proper harness for comfort over longs days in rough terrain.

Where the market falls down

Photo backpacks come in 2 camps: the huge expedition size things or small set-ups. Almost all are designed with only photo gear in mind - clearly not aimed at those of us who hike stuff into the hills. Split compartments always put the photo gear at the bottom. Harnesses are mediocre at best. Weight is high due to all the padding. Quite frankly, I'm just as well off using my Think Tank carry-on.

Regular backpacks are really designed for hiking or climbing only. No real way to put camera gear in well. In the day-pack size there are almost no dual-compartment designs to allow me to stow camera and other gear separately. Lots are also coming with these new ventilated back systems where there's a tensioned mesh against the back and gap to the pack - this moves the weight away from your back which is bad, especially for heavy loads.

I figure in today's world, I don't need to compromise or buy lots to find something suitable. I just keep plugging away until I find someone who's got it together.

Enter Kinesis.

A bit of a one-man-band enterprise, this is a novel line up of photo gear. All modular in away that fits all kinds of packs, pouches, belts and harnesses together in anyway you chose.

Their backpack offering is the Journeyman, which can be combined with all sorts of options to create the perfect set-up for your application. It's a proper backpack, with the ability to hook-in camera pouches. Pole loops & tripod mounts as standard. A host of accessories to add on.

What I ordered

A lot of gear (see picture). Pack, hydration pouch, accessory pouch, interior pouch, straps & doohickies for lashing stuff on. Clip system to attach camera to the harness.

Kinesis Journeyman componentsKinesis Journeyman (centre) and components

Configurations

The stuff I've ordered allows me to do the following:
  • Backpack, with or without camera.
  • Removable harness, removable belt - great for carry-on.
  • Extendible with the hydration pack as an extra pouch.
  • Slap everything on for a big day out.
  • Hydration pack only.
  • Camera pouch & belt as a waist pack. Add hydration pack for a lightweight all-day set-up.
  • Camera pouch as a shoulder bag.
Loads of options, great for travelling or sightseeing or hiking.

What do I think

Without using it in anger, here are the thoughts out of the box.

This thing is pretty large. Bigger than I'd expected. Pack measures 55x30x20cm (22"x12"x8"). It's a square shape, too, so you get full volume for your size. Weight is reasonable, not the lightest or heaviest. The harness is good, though, so the weight is light in the shoulders, which is what counts.

Kinesis journeyman harnessJourneyman harness system opened out
Back padding folded down & belt removed to show aluminium struts

Materials and construction are all top quality. harness sizing is pretty large. I would say larger than the website credits. I'm 6' tall, not too fat, and the medium/large harness is cinched right down when I've got it on - the smaller size would have been fine. Even then, the chest strap is at maximum extension. I went down a size on the belt and am glad I did. Side mesh pockets will actually be useful. Most sacks have very flat designs or they're small so everything falls out. Not these - expanding sides, large and a good stiff top band.

The internal pouch is excellent. The lightest I've come across for the size, and it's large. Fits easily my 4x5" field camera or the Mamiya RZ67. It's SLR plus 3 lenses territory - 70-200 stands up easily inside. Top opening is well designed. Most of the padding can be removed which is also useful.

Journeyman opened with inner pouch in place
The Pouch can it attached anywhere through the height of the pack

All of the accessories and pouches snap together easily. This is truly modular design. There are all kinds of ways to do things and I've been spending hours working out which will be best for me.

There are a few negatives. Harness strap design doesn't quite come down over the back of my shoulders as I'd like. I'd prefer the top attachment a bit further down the pack for this - allows better with distribution over the shoulders.
Attaching the inner pouch to the belt for a waist pack has a problem. The pouch is a "triple wide" which means it spans 3 attachment points. Trouble is, the attachments are evenly spaced from the belt centre so the waist pack is offset from centre.
Inner pouch attachment only has one attachment point so it hangs off the fixings. This means it's loose at the bottom which may cause it to swing around or gear to get trapped underneath. Time will tell, but I think a bottom attachment would have been good.
The front pocket, whilst useful for putting small stuff in, has no extra pockets or attachment points. In effect everything has to be loosely stored. even some Velcro strips would be useful.
Colour - it's not uniformly black but I'd like the grey side panels to have a red option. Red is a much better colour for visibility in the hills or poor weather.

I'll follow this up with an in depth review after my up-coming trip to India. It should all get a thorough working over on that one so I'll really know what it can do.

UPDATE 25/9/08: my field report now online.

Sunday, 10 August 2008

The moment in time

Cartier-Bresson had his decisive moment. Now comes the Landscapist talking about the notion of freezing time. Interesting idea, that coincided with earlier thoughts I had on "The Americans". Coincidentally, I was studying Frank's book the night before reading Mark Hobson's post. I then went and looked at his new "Shore Light" gallery. As seems to happen to me frequently, these things all came together in a series of thoughts.

When a photograph freezes a moment in time, is it any moment in time, or a very specific moment from a specific time? How is it we are able to place the picture in space and time? We often, consciously or not, derive whole stories, histories from the contents of a single image. Is the photographer helping us in that effort, or deliberately obfuscating to give only a hint or glimpse?

The stronger thought that came through, however, was the fact that many photographs give a distinct sense of specific place and time both geographically and historically. There is no getting away from the fact that "The Americans" is a slice of 1950s America, and I wrote before that the effort could easily be taken up once a generation without losing impact. It is also clear that "Shore Light" shows a sense of now about the place.

I see two reasons why this is the case. Firstly there are the obvious cultural references - clothes, cars, hairstyles. The second is in photographic style, which is much harder to put a finger on. Some of it comes from materials and technology. Some of it comes from means of presenting the subject. I wondered if this second aspect would work for other subjects? I don't know but it would be interesting to see.

Take a subject well covered over many years but I would think something without an obviously iconic shot. A great landmark that's been photographed since there were photographs. I reckon Mount Fuji in Japan would make a good example. Then take 1000 shots spread across the almost 150 years, and I bet you'd be able to pretty closely mark the timeline. There are obvious differences in processes available from late 19th century to early 21st. But I also think there would be a great deal of difference in the way the subject is presented that would change too. even such a static, simple one as that.

Maybe, then, we are capturing as much about the times of the photographer as the times and moment of the subject.

Friday, 8 August 2008

Manual, what manual?

Picked up via dpreview, this survey about technology bafflement. Doesn't surprise me. Like every bit of technology, the way you're going to get the most out of your camera is to know how to use it properly. trouble is, most people I meet want to be able to pick up the camera, point at the subject, push the button and get a good picture. back to the Instamatic days.

Therein lies the problem. There are 2 types of camera user: the Instamatic crowd who truly want point and shoot (i.e. no functions, adjustments or doodads) and those of us who want full control over everything.

It make me wonder why all those whiz bangs get added to cameras when neither group wants them.

A passing thought - the number one question I get asked by friends about their cameras: how do I turn off the flash? (Yes, I seem to be helpdesk man for cameras because I'm into photography).

Thursday, 7 August 2008

Neither here nor there follow up

Following up from yesterday, Wikipedia is already up and running with micro 4/3. Plus, it's got all the lens mount details too.

With this size, looks like an absolute winner for digital RF, given that LTM & M bayonet should be easily adapted.

That's the optimist bit. The pessimist in me thinks that this will never happen and we'll end up with a limited line of camera with crappy interfaces, no optical VF and no hot shoe for accessories either.

Wednesday, 6 August 2008

Neither here nor there

but somewhere in between.

Quite a bit of buzz on the new micro 4/3 format. RAWsumer thinks it may mark the death of digicams offering RAW, Michael Reichmann thinks it's a dead end. In a "let's weight up the evidence, fair hearing" kind of way, my thoughts (for what they're worth):

It's an interchangeable lens format. Will that really mark the doom of fixed lens cameras? I don't think so. I don't think micro 4/3 will really be small cameras, in the shirt pocket category. Look at the bigger brother: supposedly a smaller DLSR format yet the cameras aren't much smaller than their bigger sensor rivals. No one ever accuse RFs of being pocket cameras, and they're the smallest interchangeable lens cameras available (AFAIK).

I think it might offer an interesting platform for a digital rangefinder. OK, so it's got a 2x crop factor. Plus it uses what seems to be a larger mount than Leica thread mount or M. But the deal with the format is to get around all those nasty edge of sensor problems that The M8 has hit hard. I don't agree with Reichmann that the M8 has proven the way for large sensor RF, quite the opposite. I think it's so beset with inherent problems that different solutions may be needed (many of which may be software, rather than hardware). Still, I think there is potential here.

Will it rival DSLRs? I don't think so, at least not the larger ones. Optical viewfinding is still superior to electronic and this new format removes the possibility of reflex viewing (hence my thought on RF). Might make an interesting alternative to the entry level DLSRs, but I bet it'll never compete on price (which is almost the number one differentiator in brands for real buyers).

That mount is still large, as I've mentioned. Smaller it may be, but only that the big 4/3. Compared to RF mounts, I pretty sure it's jolly large. which starts to preclude really small lenses. For me, a small lens needs to have a small diameter for comfortable holding, not just be pancake flat. I don't think this large mount, aimed at motor driven lenses, will give that small diameter I'm looking for (as a point of comparison with SLRs, I think only the smallest, cheapest, non-IS lenses come close to being small diameter, and optically they're pretty rubbish).

So where do I think it fits: in that medium size, carry all day slot currently held by RF cameras. Give me a small package with a good optical VF and small, fast primes and I think it would be useful. With a decent range zoom as well, it would make a strong travel companion, that might convince me to leave the SLRs at home on trips, especially with the bike. I still want a high quality compact with RAW, for the shirt-pocket option.

Too familiar or too superficial?

Picking up on a running theme of late, and following from Doug Stockdale's comment on my wet weather post, is the idea of becoming over familiar with things.

For residents of Northern Europe, rain is an everyday occurrence (OK, maybe not every day, but pretty frequent), whereas in sunny SoCal it's more like a desert. As Doug points out, rain for him is pretty unusual.

So can I be too familiar with rainy conditions. Have I blocked out the rain effect so that everything looks the same to me wet or dry? Can we start to tune out subtle variations because they are too familiar to us? That may not be a bad thing, instead of observing the superficial differences (in this case the weather), we might be able to get past it and deeper into seeing the subject. On the other hand, it might be that an important part of the character of a subject is lost to us as we've tuned it out.

I think I may have to make an effort to walk familiar streets on a rainy day (and when I've got suitable clothing to hand) to see if I can spot the differences it brings, delving into this conundrum.

Sunday, 3 August 2008

Wet weather photography

It's raining here, has been since mid-afternoon yesterday. Not the weather to get me out on the bike (but I enjoyed the sunny morning conditions yesterday), nor is it weather to inspire me to take the camera out.

This is a recurring theme - I don't take photographs in the rain. Even if I happen to be out in the weather, with a camera to hand, I don't press the shutter. Why not? Partly, obviously, is the general desire not to be out getting wet, nor risking screwing up the camera. Main, though, I think it's because I don't really see images in the rain. There aren't subjects that inspire me that wouldn't be done better when it's dry.

What is a wet weather aesthetic anyway? I've seen some stuff done in the wet, and it seems to focus around reflections & puddles. Gets to being the rain equivalent of glorious sunsets.

Anyone out there actually making pictures in the rain? What are the things you're looking for that's particular to the conditions?

Friday, 1 August 2008

The megapixel race is not over

There was much made of the new Panasonic DMC-LX3 camera announcement that stated that sensor had been enlarged (to a whopping 1/1.63") and resolution restricted to 10.1Mp. So is it a slow-down in resolution. Not likely, all the other, more basic, cameras announced at the same time had increased resolution on their predecessors to 14+Mp. Likewise other manufacturers. Until the sales process (from marketing to the stores) can get it into their collective heads that people need better pixels, not more pixels, the more this rubbish will continue.


The good news is we're getting another compact with RAW mode, burst shooting an wide-angle. The lens is even pretty fast. I've seen some (low res) first shots and low light performance seems decent. One wonders if there will be a Leica-branded version, too. For once I'm actually pretty interested from a buying pov in small cameras. Both this and the Ricoh GX200 look like pretty good contenders for my cash.

Thursday, 31 July 2008

Depth and new ideas

I've written before about my personal inclination to wide rather than deep, but came to a realisation in striking contrast to that notion last night.

I am, yet again, in Norway (in fact this is my last planned trip for the current project) which has given me much time in one location. While I was living here I did little photography of the town and, in fact, I have probably discovered more locations in these few weeks of visits than I did in several years of living here.

Where I come from in the UK is very close to many of the biggest tourist attractions in the the country and yet several of the major draws I have never visited, despite passing them frequently.

What has all this to do with photography? Where is the wide/deep connection?

For my present travels, I have made cause to get out with the camera frequently - maybe 4 or 5 days out of a 2 week trip. In a small town, that means covering quite a lot of ground multiple times. As I've little else to do of an evening, it is a good thing to do.
My initial motivation was to put together my photobook, which became my fist SoFoBoMo effort. I have since expanding the pictures under that theme and have plenty of material for a decent 50-60 image book. But then what? Having covered that particular view of the town, I have found myself looking for new ways to approach the same subjects or inventing mini-projects. This is, i suppose, what is traditionally meant by going deep.

On the other hand, I am not so sure that much of this photography is actually truly a deep exploration of the town. Many of the subjects I have photographed are anonymous of location. Much "deep" work I see by others is similarly generic. Is that deep in the sense of exploring a given location, or merely photographing details as an entirely different subject matter? My feeling is the latter. What I have realised is that my continuing to photograph the same locations repeatedly is giving me a new perspective on looking at the world in general. In looking for details, I notice details.

[A short aside as lead into the next thoughts: I watched a TV programme the other night that talked about the psychology of living in the city versus the country. The hypothesis was proposed, with some example, that city dwellers need to skip over details to avoid overload. They move faster, do more things but maybe - my interpretation - are a little more superficial (maybe target focused) in their interactions with their surroundings. It was given as example how we all skip certain details that aren't important to us at the time, in the city there are more details to skip.]

And so I have possibly come to know this one town better than I did. Apart from places I've lived, I never visited anywhere as regularly, especially with a view to photography. I think I skip the places I lived not from lack of interest but from a sense of utility. The place I live takes on a functional character, rather than being a place to explore and understand. I don't make time to just go out and photograph things. On my trips to Norway the time comes for free, so getting out is easy.

So am I getting any deeper? I not convinced I am but I certainly teaching myself some new ways of looking at the world that are likely to affect my future photographic work.

Wednesday, 30 July 2008

ProStrap wrist strap: a mini review

UPDATED

I mentioned on my write-up of the Zeiss Ikon that I'm using a wrist strap with it. I've been looking for a wrist strap for a while. When I'm around town I like to wrap the strap around my left wrist and carry the camera in my left hand, down by my side. People don't really notice you've got it and it can be deployed for shooting in an instant. Wrapping lengths of neck strap is not ideal, however. I also don't want a quick-release design, so it can't be easily unsnapped and the camera dropped.

The doodad I'm using is a Deluxe Belt ProStrap, from ProStrap.com. I thought it was worth a mention, particularly as I'm pretty happy with it.

It's a simple device, a leather strap that attaches to the camera at one end and has a wide section to go around your wrist at the other. Price is modest, postage fast. Construction quality is very nice.

The main thing I like is the length. It's just the right size to go around my wrist and allow me to grasp the camera without a lot of excess strap material. It is also just long enough that I can carry the whole thing by the strap with the camera dangling (not recommended).
It is very grippy, having a rubberised backing - there is no way it will accidentally slip off the wrist. There is also a tightening ring to cinch in around the wrist, which I find helps tidy it all up when holding the camera.

If you're like me and tend to carry your camera in one hand, especially smaller cameras, I'd highly recommend giving a ProStrap a go. There are lots of options and there can't be too many cameras they won't fit. (I do know I couldn't fit one to my Mamiya RZ67, but then why would I want to?)

UPDATE 31/7/08 - a minor correction to the above. On closer inspection (i.e. actually lloking at the thing) I realise that the back of the wrist strap is NOT rubberised, as I stated above, but is in fact the brushed reverse surface of the leather. It actually has a very nice feel next the the skin, after a while you forget there's a strap there at all.

Seesaw: interesting online magazine

While doing a search for some photographers, I came across Seesaw, which is an online photo mag. Interesting concept and some pretty good work included. Seems to be an entirely non-commercial undertaking. Well worth a look.

Tuesday, 29 July 2008

Does Art follow technique?

UPDATE: this time with the links

There are a couple of interesting posts and discussions over a T.O.P. (here and here) on Daguerreotypes that raised some thoughts in my mind about the form of photographic art. Not so much about the Daguerreotypes, per se, but the notion coming from the discussions that particular methods yields better results. An age old question in photography, I might even have mused on it before.

To my points (as ever, more questions than answers) - does a photograph have inherent qualities irrespective of display medium? I'm pretty certain that's a no. Apart from the subject being the same regardless of display method, many of the Art qualities - including the ability to raise emotional response - stem from the means of presentation (traditionally the print form, but now we need to include electronic means, too).
But then, do certain qualities stem from the particular display process, which the artist then manipulates to their desire? By implication, does this mean that certain types of subject cannot be adequately represented by certain types of process?

The converse can also be asked, which is where I came from. The original discussion stemmed from the reproduction versus original of the Daguerreotype. At the time, there were limited photographic processes and so photographers were limited in their choices. Does this mean that the qualities we associate with those processes were happenstance at the time? Was the aim the same as today and the result dictated by process? Or, did the artist choose particular subjects or rendering to suit the medium and if so, would they have chosen to do something differently with access to other display media?

That opens up a slightly wider thought - is the Artist quality of a photography then inherent in the subject or by necessity dictated by the combination of subject and display medium? And, on a similar theme, can we render the same subject (maybe from the raw same source) differently for different media and maintain the artistic qualities?

I'm never sure that I agree with photographers who claim that they can only achieve the results they wish with one particular process. Just because one individual cannot match the effects in an ink jet print as they do with a traditional wet print doesn't necessarily mean that it is not possible. By extension, I don't believe that any one process has inherently better artistic value than another, it is specific to a particular way of representing a particular subject.

Monday, 28 July 2008

Zeiss Ikon: a review for the RF newbie

I finally succumbed to temptation and bought myself a rangefinder, a shiny new Zeiss Ikon with a Voigtlander 40 f/1.4 Nokton Classic. As this is the first RF I've used, I thought I'd give my impressions as someone coming fresh in from the (D)SLR world.

What I've noticed is most RF reviews are written by (and largely for) RF enthusiasts - preaching to the choir. There's precious little for those coming at it new. Thus my thoughts on the matter. All subjective, and the odd tangent. Plus, bear in mind I am an engineer so "devices" are a natural draw for me.

I've written before as to why I'm interested in a rangefinder, and what I'm going to be using it for. I'm going into this well aware of the limitations which are fine by me. It's exactly the genre's strengths that make it attractive for the sort of street photography I want to use it for.

This is really early use - I shot the equivalent of a couple of rolls before loading the first film and now I've shot a couple of rolls since. No results yet, they've not been processed. But frankly, this write-up is not about the pictures: that's all about the right exposure on the right film and any camera can cover that. This is all about handling.

First appearances

The 2 things that first struck me we "wow, that's small", especially when I opened the lens box and second, "wow, that's heavy" when I picked it up. Actually, the body just seems quite heavy due to its dense, metal construction. I reality, it's not really any heavier than a small DSLR body. The lens is, however, tiny but again metal construction makes it seem heavier. I'm not going to weigh it all, I'll come back to the weight thing later.

EOS500 vs Zeiss IkonCanon EOS500 next to the Zeiss Ikon. This is a small SLR set-up, the ZI is very similar is size.

In actual fact, it's not that small. If you're coming from small DLSRs or P&S cameras this will feel like a lump. If, like me, you're coming from the mid-sized cameras, this will seem reasonably sized, but not small. Only someone handling large pro gear, MF, LF etc would think a rangefinder small. Most reviewers seem to be in the last camp and seriously underplay the size. This is not a pocket camera.

Fiddling with levers and dials, turning the lens controls etc gives one a feeling of quality construction. This is not about materials. [An aside - high quality metal materials are generally lighter than the cheap stuff. Modern alloys have pushed up performance while reducing weight. A lump of cast iron is not going to be a quality product.] The few plastic parts feel pretty solid, using decent material. The mainly metal body feels appropriately weighty but not like a lump of lead.

The main thing that gives a quality feel, however, is fit and finish. Everything fits right. No slop or slack bits. Nothing over tight either. Just nice, smooth, clean fitting parts. The lens snaps on just so, the lens hood likewise. All the levers and dials run smoothly without any loose feeling. This is really nice in a world of loose manufacturing tolerances for mass production. Even the best Canon gear I've got seems cheaply constructed by comparison.

Holding the camera

This is a bit strange having spent so long on SLRs. I actually had to get out my old film P&S (A Konica Pop) to remind myself what it felt like to hold such a device. Without the moulded hand grip or the weight of a large lens to balance, I need to hold the camera differently, especially to focus it (more later). I don't need or want to rest the camera in the palm of my left hand - it's more a fingers around the side sort of thing. For many, this is the normal way to hold a camera, for me it's taking some getting used to. It's not uncomfortable, just different.

Konica Pop vs Zeiss IkonMy old Konica Pop next to the Zeiss Ikon. Old P&S cameras weren't pocket sized, either.

Carrying it around, I use a wrist strap (more on what I use in another post) and hold it my left hand. This leaves my right hand free for general use (I'm right handed) and allows me to bring the camera to eye in the least time. The reasonable size, especially the lens diameter, makes it easy to carry with my fingers wrapped around the lens. This is a pretty inconspicuous way to carry a camera. I have quite short fingers and find carrying an SLR in this manner uncomfortable after a while, even with the smallest lenses (with the DLSRs, I can't even do so they're so large). Not so here. As a result, it feels like a much smaller and lighter camera to carry around. The weight then doesn't become an issue. It just feels light and easy in the hand regardless.

Viewfinding

I've no problem with the offset VF. I've no problem seeing everything in the VF (shutter speed, frame lines, focus patch) even with glasses on. I did notice early on that ones eye has to be aligned just so to see the focus patch but now it comes naturally.

As many note, compared to even a good SLR VF, this is big and bright and clear. Seeing things and focussing in low light is easy.

Framelines will take some getting used to. Yes, I can see things outside the frame but as a long-term SLR users, this is actually distracting at present, rather than helpful. Another thing to get used to.

On framelines, the 40mm Nokton brings up the 50mm framelines. I've taken some test shots to see if I prefer the 50mm or 35mm frames. If the 35mm frame is better, then the lens tab will need a little modifying to get the right auto select.

Focus

What a joy! I really don't much like manual focussing with an SLR (even in medium format it can be a bit tricky). It's all visual acuity. Get the wrong dioptre adjustment or look through your glasses wrong and focus can be off. With the mechanical style of focussing with the RF focus patch, I can even focus without my glasses (I get the same results with or without). Much, much quicker manual focus.

Only problem is finding a comfortable way to hold the camera so I can easily use the focus tab on the lens. The finger recess never seems quite in the right place. I'm getting better but practice is needed. This will be a lens by lens problem.

Metering

Obviously, I haven't checked any output but it's in the range I'm expecting. I ran a test against my Canon SLR and got pretty much the same results, which is good. I can then quickly know how much compensation to add in any situation, don't have to relearn anything.

With the shutter speed showing up in the VF, there is a slight problem. It only shows whole stops, while the electronic AE is continuous. Of course, plenty of latitude in film and mixed light always needs a couple of meter checks anyway. One thing I don't like (a personal thing) are the 1/3 stop compensation settings. I'm a half-stop man as I find it easier to do the calcs in my head.

Film handling

Actually had to read the manual to know how to load the film. The tab slots are a little odd. Easy enough to use, just different than anything I've used before. It all very smooth and film loading is a snap.

I need to get back into the habit of winding the film after each shot. I've become so used to auto wind that I'm out of the habit. With medium format film, I'm working slower so always cock the lever just before a shot rather than just after. RF is all about speed - being ready to go.

The most disappointing thing on the whole camera is the rewind lever. It's a little fiddly, too small and feels flimsy. Actual wind feel is nice and there's a nice ratcheting sound as the film spools back. One odd thing is releasing the film cartridge. One has to pop the rewind lever down manually. even my old Konica Pop has this built into the door release mechanism. Again, a bit fiddly.

A further note on the lens

This isn't a lens review and I'm not really qualified to do that well. As long as it gets the light to the film without too much bother I'm quite happy.

I do love the small size an the tidy handling. All of that quality feel is there. Controls are plastic but good stuff and it's not a problem. Aperture stops are nice and positive but not too stiff.

The lens hood snaps on precisely and easily, with 3 working positions. It's spring loaded for release which prevents accidental release. All nice.

The lens cap is the best I've used. I'm sure I've seen criticism of Voigtlander lens caps in the past but the design has changed. The pinch tabs are curved for ones fingers and slightly raised in the middle for a firm grip. It can also be pinched from the outside, too, so it'll work any way you want. A small detail but shows the company cares about the small stuff.

Vioigtlander 40 Nokton vs EF 28 2.8 & EF 50 1.8The Voigtlander 40 f/1.4 nokton Classic flanked by the Canon EF 28 f/2.8 and EF 50 F/1.8.
These are the smallest lenses Canon makes and they are much larger than the Voigtlander, especially in diameter.


Conclusions

Well, I'm pretty happy. I did think long and hard about what and why for this camera. I tried my old SLR in a sort of RF manner to help me realise I needed something more suited to fast manual focus street use. Handling lives up to the reputation and I'm enjoying the RF way of using a camera for those specific tasks. It is not, and will not become, a do-all camera (no such thing). it's not an SLR, and I'm not expecting it to handle that way. As I use a variety of cameras, I'm happy to switch working & handling methods as I go. If you're a dyed-in-the-wool SLR nut, you may not like the change.

There are some aspects that will definitely take some practice to get honed but I'm sure that will come. As I'm more likely to take a camera with me if it's this nice to use, it'll get plenty of use. I don't mind the film thing. Sure, digital can be a whole lot more convenient but no one yet makes a digital RF that I'd be prepared to buy (and the Leica M8 is technically far from acceptable for me, let alone price).

Who should buy an RF? Well first, you've got to have some cash. There are some decent deals on lenses on ebay (if you avoid all the over-priced Leica) but I've not seen too many decent bodies. Seems a lot of people are buying up cheap Bessa kits, deciding they don't like it and flogging them off in short order. I would not rate the Zeiss Ikon a cheap camera, but it's pretty affordable if you run a mid-sized DSLR kit. lots of Voigtlander 35mm f/1.4 Nokton Classics, probably due to disappointment (it gets the worst reviews of all the current Voigtlander line - this is why I went with the 40mm).

If you don't do much discrete, fast street photography, I wouldn't bother. If you don't like film, go elsewhere. If you are into those things, I think a rangefinder would suit you well. I don't think there is another type of camera that can do that fast, discrete thing so well. Plus, you get a fine mechanical device to play with.

Saturday, 26 July 2008

Ilford Delta 100: a first look

Untitled, Kristiansund, May 2008

Some while back I was looking for a daylight complement to my usual Ilford HP5+ black and white film, something to offer more detail and better response in bright light. So I've tried Delta 100. Only a single roll so far, but enough for me to see some distinct differences.

My recent picturing around Kristiansund has been, in broad terms, a mixture of evening street shooting and daytime landscapes. HP5+ is great for closer work and low light but is too "sketchy" for detailed landscapes. Enter Delta.

Some things I've noticed

With HP5+, I find the shadow detail to be excellent but it doesn't carry highlights well. This is mostly due to the mixture of the grain and the scanning process. I can't say anything about development techniques - I send it off to the local pro lab for that. As a result, I use a -0.5 to -1 EV compensation on my Canon SLR, which gives great results.

Delta is a different beast entirely. I was exposing as for HP5+ (-0.5EV) in bright sunny conditions - similar to anything I'd do with any camera/film. Results aren't quite what I expected. fine detail rendition is excellent, highlight detail as good as anything I've seen but shadows are distinctly disappointing.

It seems as if HP5+ has a sharp roll-off in the highlights (in terms of rendered detail - combining both exposure, development and grain effects) but a long tail at the low end. with Delta it seems to be the other way around. I reckon i could happily over expose by a stop with Delta, which I wouldn't dare with HP5+. More testing definitely required, I think.

Ice cream and beer

A great combination...

Ice cream and beerIce cream and beer, Oslo, May 2008

Something from little

Back in May, when I was in Oslo, I complained of not seeing much. Well I've just finished working the roll, and found quite a few decent shots. Here are a few:

Oslo, May 2008Untitled, Oslo, May 2008

Oslo, May 2008Untitled, Oslo, May 2008

Lunchtime entertainmentLunchtime entertainment, Oslo, May 2008

Sunday, 20 July 2008

Creating movement: the wind in action

Something I mused about for my Processes of Nature series was capturing the motion of the wind in a meaningful manner. On one of my photo walks in Norway recently I was playing around with some ideas. Here I'm going to run through what I was doing and whether I think it's working.

The trick, I reckon, is to get the sense of movement by having some fixed reference in the shot. If everything looks blurry, it might just be camera shake (photog movement) rather than subject movement. So I'm looking for something that resembles the classic sports shot with the subject blurred against a sharp background (or vice versa).

I tried a few things this time, all hand-held as I didn't have a tripod with me:

- Single frame, slower shutters. Using my 17-55 IS, I can handhold pretty slow at 17mm, probably down around 1/4s.
- Couple of frames blended (not very successful here)
- Multiple frames blended in several ways, building on my "virtual ND filter" that I used in an earlier post.

Here are the results

Single frame at 1/8s

Several frames blended using Photomatix Pro

Several frames blended by hand in Photoshop (lots of opacity adjustments)

I think this is showing promise, especially the blends. I don't think the proper effect can be gained consistently with a single frame.

What things would I look for in future?
First up, a longer base shutter speed for blending - maybe around 1/2s. Short speeds are tending to mean too much, or too irregular, movement between exposures.
Second, I like the manual blended; I can control the effect each frame has on the blur. Good point to start is us the base image as one near the centre of the movement range, then progressively decrease the opacity as the movement gets further from that central point. Gives a more natural look. For auto blending I'd probably go with more frames (I used up to six here: 1 fill of the 20D's buffer).
Definitely a tripod, otherwise the fixed reference won't be.